Murdick's Fudge

Pros - The best fudge you'll ever have, Comes with a Knife

Cons - A little too expensive, Only on the Island, Only in the Summer

Our choice - Cranberry Fudge

Score - 9.0/10

5 Circuit Avenue

Oak Bluff, MA

1-800-55-FUDGE

888-553-8343

2 other places in Vineyard Haven and Edgartown